Anyone working in a tech field with an aversion to flux is in the wrong business to begin with. Besides, it's not like he's so allergic to it considering the P12 update to warrant such conjecture. We know like many of us here, he finds using soft synths on a comp to be work, so the advantage is purely with the interface and being self-contained. I for one am happy to use presets from Dexed (which is free), but I'm never going to sit and design my own patch on it. Although, I will agree a module would be a good place to start instead of the other way around. It could come in considerably cheaper than anything else in their line-up, while having no real competition (the Digitone would be a toy in comparison if done right) & certainly not further add to self-cannibalization. I'm not sure how many more flagships the market will support and the low-end analog portion has been fully saturated for some time now. FM has a lot of untapped potential in large part because no one has pulled of an appealing interface yet for those looking for something tactile.
FM has a lot of untapped potential in large part because no one has pulled of an appealing interface yet for those looking for something tactile.
Quoting that last line twice for its eloquence and relevance value. The question is -- has nobody done it due to lack of ideas, or is it because the nature of FM synths and the amount of knob madness that would need to be done right, presents a bit of cost proposition dilemma? If you need $1,500 worth of knobs to drive $50 worth of code and DSP, will the consumer be happy?
Take a look at the best FM programming interface I've seen to date... and we are only looking at one page:
https://imgur.com/a/Z6YVvzUWhat would the MSRP be on a "wall sized configuration of knobs" that could offer same? And would consumers be happy when they found that regardless of controls available to manipulate everything properly, it is still orders of magnitude less intuitive than subtractive synthesis? Sure, if could be a menu diver, but that is what the DX7 was and NOBODY likes programming a DX7. It got where it was because it sounded good and VSTs weren't available at the time.
Now... do I think there is a way it could be done? Simplified in a way so that not EVERYTHING possible with FM was on the panel, but enough to capture the soul and still be musical? Yes and there are those, maybe Dave and crew who are talented enough to make that a possibility. I just wonder if it's really in his wheelhouse to do so, or if analog is what he does best?