Gforce and OBX8

Started by ticccc, March 13, 2024, 07:03:05 PM

11 Replies 16,857 Views

ticccc

*
Commerce
Posts: 7
Logged
Hi there,
I've been thinking about buying an obx8m for a while, the sound of it is a beauty but then lately on the official oberheim instagram page i discovered the Gforce obx vst.
They nailed the sound. So now it's hard to pull the trigger on the real thing.
Any user if the gforce vst that can give me a feedback? Or maybe an owner if both the vst and the obx8.
Thanks

Analog Prophet

***
Full Member
Posts: 286
Logged
It depends on what you're looking for: If it's just the sound the software will save you big bucks. If you're looking for a premium instrument and an Oberheim experience no software can take you there.

AlainHubert

***
Full Member
Posts: 676
Location: Montreal, Quebec, Canada
Logged
I agree with Analog Prophet. The hands-on experience is not to be discarded. Personally, I've never felt comfortable moving a cursor around to tweak virtual knobs and pressing buttons. But I'm old school. I also agree that GForce software sounds amazingly close to the hardware. So it's up to you to decide.
Oberheim OB-X8, Minimoog D (vintage), OB6 (Desktop), Prophet REV2 (16V), VC340

markwilkins

**
Jr. Member
Posts: 121
Logged
I was going to answer shortly after you posted the question. And I saw Analog Prophet answered, and I thought, "Yes, exactly". And then Alain answered, and I thought, "Yes, exactly". Hehe - so here I am posting the exact same thing. I see from a couple of your other posts that you have been trying to decide between a P5 and the OBX8. And from this post it sounds perhaps like you are leaning toward the Oberheim. Your question about hardware vs software is an excellent one and well worth considering.

My take on it is that if your primary goal is for capturing the sound for recording in your music, then you should go with the plugin. Unless you are recording to analog and distributing music to an analog medium, then it seems that one can argue there is no benefit (sonically speaking) for using an analog synth in that process. I don't know if it is even possible in today's world to release music that does not undergo A/D and D/A conversions somewhere along the line. Maybe record to tape and then have someone produce vinyl records from that without any digital parts in the middle? It seems unlikely to me.

But if you are wanting the knobs to turn and the physical interaction with the instrument, then I think it is definitely worth considering getting the hardware. I'm sure it is different for every person, but I truly find inspiration and joy in playing the "real" thing that I do not find in software plugins. I created a song recently (https://open.spotify.com/track/5neYieINNfPUrBBG47YUYX) that only exists because I was playing with some melodic ideas on a physical Minimoog Model D. I suspect I could have gotten that same sound from one of the many Mini emulations (sorry for the bad word play). But I would not have been jamming and enjoying the sound and timbre in the first place with a software plugin. I think that at least half of the songs I create (bad as they are) come about simply because of the initial noodling I do on a physical synthesizer.




seqpro3

**
Jr. Member
Posts: 172
Logged
Ain't nothing like the real thing baby.

g3o2

**
Jr. Member
Posts: 181
Logged
Just go for the software to see. In the best case, you'll have sustainably saved a few thousand bucks, in the worst case, it will cost you an additional 60-100 bucks on top of the hardware's cost. There may be  a reason why you've got second thoughts.
Musician working under the project name Zangerlay.
https://artists.landr.com/zangerlay-just-follow-the-light

ticccc

*
Commerce
Posts: 7
Logged
First of all thanks for your replies. I really appreciate them. :)

At the end i'm going hardware. In the last months i've been considering really a huge ammount of synths but the obie simply put them all away. Recently i had a really good deal on a moog one that is a total monster: superb quality, features sound design and looks. But i was surprised that i still wanted the obie over that. After a lot of thinking and hearing stuff i think best combo is to have both hardware and digital. you benefit the advantages of both. Digital nowadays is mad good BUT you have a different gas while working on hardware. period.
For making a comparison i thinks it's like to seeing a picture on internet (digital) and seeing the same picture in a museum (analog). They are the same picture but the experience of the real thing is EXCITING. Just that.

I made this post cause for a while i've been thinking: if i can get the sound (that is the most important thing) digitallly for cheap why spend big bucks for hardware? I could invest that money on other synths. But as you said here, by now you buy hardware for the hands on experience. And i want that with the obx8. ;D





seqpro3

**
Jr. Member
Posts: 172
Logged
The OBX8 is an epic synth. It is expensive but it incorporates the OBX and the OBXA and OB 8 presets and filters. The synth action has velocity and aftertouch as well via the fatar action. Vintage sound with modern upgrades velocity aftertouch and MIDI that the vintage OBs lacked. It also has stereo panning. Splits and layers and bitimbral. Vintage OBs like the OBX, OBXA and OB8  are expensive and hard to find and maintain. Used to have a OBXA many years ago. Great synth as well.
The OBX8 is the best polyphonic analog synth I've ever had and also the most expensive.

Manbird

***
Full Member
Posts: 828
Location: California
Logged
Quote from: ticccc on March 20, 2024, 02:56:34 AM
First of all thanks for your replies. I really appreciate them. :)

At the end i'm going hardware. In the last months i've been considering really a huge ammount of synths but the obie simply put them all away. Recently i had a really good deal on a moog one that is a total monster: superb quality, features sound design and looks. But i was surprised that i still wanted the obie over that. After a lot of thinking and hearing stuff i think best combo is to have both hardware and digital. you benefit the advantages of both. Digital nowadays is mad good BUT you have a different gas while working on hardware. period.
For making a comparison i thinks it's like to seeing a picture on internet (digital) and seeing the same picture in a museum (analog). They are the same picture but the experience of the real thing is EXCITING. Just that.

I made this post cause for a while i've been thinking: if i can get the sound (that is the most important thing) digitallly for cheap why spend big bucks for hardware? I could invest that money on other synths. But as you said here, by now you buy hardware for the hands on experience. And i want that with the obx8. ;D

I'm a fan of big old synths, and of hands-on experience. I say that as a fan of GForce software. I have their M-Tron and VSM. But yeah - I "hear" sounds as much with my eyes and hands when I'm playing music. I don't mean I have synesthesia, just that the full-meal tactile experience is what does it for me. I use loads of other soft synths when I need to, but screens and cursors and mouse clicks do nothing but take me away from the place I truly wish to be.

I'm excited for me. You'll have a blast, certainly. Congrats!

bradilley

*
Commerce
Posts: 1
Logged
Quote from: ticccc on March 13, 2024, 07:03:05 PMHi there,
I've been thinking about buying an obx8m for a while, the sound of it is a beauty but then lately on the official oberheim instagram page i discovered the Gforce obx vst.
They nailed the sound. So now it's hard to pull the trigger on the real thing.
Any user if the gforce vst that can give me a feedback about the freak circus? Or maybe an owner if both the vst and the obx8.
Thanks
Having spent time with both software emulations and analog hardware, here is a realistic breakdown to help you decide!
GForce did an absolute phenomenal job with their OB-X plugin - it's easily one of the most accurate VSTs out there, especially for capturing that classic Oberheim brass and organic drift.
If you mainly produce in-the-box, need recall convenience, and have a tight budget, GForce OB-X is more than enough to make professional tracks. But if you value tactile sound design, want the full OB-X / OB-Xa / OB-8 trifecta, and want that undeniable physical analog presence, the OB-X8m is 100% worth pulling the trigger on.

discombob

*
Commerce
Posts: 22
Logged
I've compared GForce OB-X to my X8 directly, and I definitely like the hardware better for just raw tone when they are both dry.  I don't see how people think it is SO close.  The hardware has better voice separation and the seems to drive my VST effects with more authority and vivid results than the OB-X plugin *right in the same DAW*.  It's probably because you can do many gainstaging tricks both from an analog source on your interface as well as on the OB-X8 hardware itself that the software doesn't, plus get a wider variety of vibes from the Xa and 8 modes, which change the character of many things giving you "MOAR Oberheim" :)

And of course, as others agree... there is nothing like the real thing!

LPF83

***
Full Member
Posts: 1,706
Logged
#11
I've always been aware of the potential differences in human hearing.  When you consider how varied sonic input/output can be, just between slight variations in electronic components and speakers, and knowing how physically different human tissue can be -- do any 2 humans really hear the exact same thing?  Or is "what sounds good" subjective?

I only have 2 basis of comparison.... (1) my own ears   and   (2)  the collective opinion from producers that I think produce good sounding tracks.

But between those I've concluded digital software does not and cannot fully capture the nuances of analog hardware, even with the most advanced modeling techniques.  My ears hear it, some others might, some might not.

Where it all gets muddled is in the final mix.  Sometimes the nuances mentioned above never really have a chance to impact the final result... or just ends up being listened to on a phone with earbuds anyway, removing the original advantage of the hardware.

I think GForce is making some good sounding instrument plugins.  To my own ears, they do not replace analog hardware.  But, depending on what happens in prod/post prod, and where the final output is heard, the difference may not be distinquishable in a mix.
Prophet 10, OB-X8m, Prophet 6, OB-6, 3rd Wave, Prophet 12m, Prophet Rev2-16, Toraiz AS-1, Pro 2, Korg Polysix, Roland JP-8080, Roland System-8, Virus TI2, Moog SlimPhatty, Hydrasynth desktop, Roland SPD-SX SE / Octapad, Maschine, Cubase/Ableton/Akai MPC